Scored a 2024 thriller a 3 but kept thinking about it for 3 days

I gave that new movie everyone is talking about a 3 out of 10 on my cozy rating sheet last Friday. The plot had holes and the ending felt rushed, but I couldn't stop replaying one specific scene with the lighthouse keeper. That made me wonder if my scoring is too harsh on atmosphere over logic. Does anyone else find they rate low on first watch but the number goes up after a few nights of mulling it over?

1 comments

1 Comment

taylor.paige12d ago

Stop overthinking it, a 3 means it was flawed.