Gave my 5 year old rating system a shot on a rainy Tuesday and the numbers surprised me
For about 5 years I've kept a little notebook where I rate everything I watch or play on a 1 to 10 scale, mostly just to remember what I thought before I forget it. Last week I went back and added up the scores for every movie I rated between January and March, which came to 41 films, and the average was a 6.2, way lower than the 7.4 I assumed I was giving out. Turns out I rate stuff harshly in the first sitting and then soften by a point or two on a rewatch, so half my notebook was basically two different people talking. I tried a fix where I wait 3 days before writing the score down, just a quick note on the movie and the number after the fact, and my picks feel steadier now, closer to what I actually think a month later. It's not a big deal but it made me trust my own list again, and I caught 4 movies I'd written off too fast, one of them a quiet little Irish drama from 2019 that I bumped from a 5 to a 7. So now the notebook is more honest and less of a mood swing log. Curious if anyone here scores right after watching or waits a bit, and if waiting changed your numbers too.
Ha, so you basically spent five years running a study on your own mood swings and the notebook was the only one who noticed. The two different people thing is funny because I bet the rainy Tuesday guy gives out way more 4s than the sunny Friday guy does. I score right after watching and my list is probably full of lies, but the 3 day wait idea is tempting since I've got a few 5s in there that might deserve better.