Loading…
35
Vent: Our club voted to skip the 'boring' chapters in 'Moby-Dick' and I think it ruined the whole point.
We were six weeks into the book and everyone was groaning about the cetology chapters. The vote was 8 to 3 to just skip from Chapter 32 to the final chase. I argued that those dense, technical chapters ARE the book's atmosphere, that the grind of the details makes Ahab's madness feel real. We read the ending and half the group said it felt 'random and over the top.' Well, yeah, you cut out the 400 pages of buildup that gives it weight. Has anyone else's group tried to cut corners on a classic and totally missed the author's intent?
3 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In3 Comments
oscarb716mo ago
Honestly my high school class tried that with the battle scenes in War and Peace. Tbh skipping the "boring" war stuff just left us with a bunch of Russians arguing in drawing rooms, which made zero sense. You gotta suffer through the slow parts to get why the ending hits.
5
paige_ellis596mo ago
Okay but the "suffer through the slow parts" line is a bit off. It's not about suffering. Those whale chapters in Moby-Dick are where Melville builds his whole weird world. You're supposed to get a little lost in it, like being stuck on a ship with nothing but weird facts and big thoughts. Skipping them is like fast-forwarding through the quiet parts of a song just to hear the chorus. The noise at the end only makes sense because of the quiet that came before.
3
shane_wilson4mo ago
Holding a vote on which chapters to skip in a book club seems like overthinking it to me. People get so caught up in whether they're reading it the "right" way that they forget it's just a book. If the group wasn't feeling the whale anatomy lessons, maybe the problem wasn't the skipping, but that nobody actually wanted to read Moby-Dick in the first place. Sometimes a boring book is just a boring book, not a profound test of endurance.
2