My hammer marks went from 3/16 deep dents to smooth in 6 months, here is what actually changed
Six months ago my hammer faces looked like I was beating hot metal with a rock, and every piece I forged had those deep 3/16 inch dents I could not file out without losing the shape. I finally sat down and dressed both faces on my 2.5 lb cross pein last October, crowned the edges and knocked the sharp corners back, and the difference in one afternoon was nuts. The big thing was my anvil height, I had it at 29 inches because that is what the stand came out to, and a guy at the Central States meet in Springfield had me stack it up to my knuckles at 34 inches. Turns out I was swinging from my shoulder instead of my elbow, so my hits were heavy and wild. I also dropped my heat, I was working way too cold and that is what made the dents stick instead of flow. I still get the occasional deep one when I rush, but the last batch of 10 bottle openers came out with almost no cleanup. Has anyone else found that anvil height fixed more of their hammer problems than the hammer itself?